Egg Naughty or Nice | Silent Night, Deadly Night Themed Cocktail

Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into Charles E. Sellier Jr.’s 1984 Silent Night, Deadly Night and couldn’t decide whether we’d be naughty or nice! Either way someone should be punished for how good this drink was! Cheers to kicking off the holiday horror season!


  • 6 oz Egg Nog
  • 1 oz Hennessey
  • 1 oz Bailey’s Red Velvet Cake Liqueur
  • Cinnamon


Step 1

In a glass, add egg nog, hennessey, and then red velvet cake liqueur. Stir with a bar spoon and garnish with a dash of cinnamon. Cheers!

Vivi Rating: 3

Erick Rating: 3.5

Shaken Not Scared Rating: 3.25

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!


Silent Night, Deadly Night (1984)

Vivi Rating: 7.5

Erick Rating: 7

Shaken Not Scared Rating: 7.25

Erick & Vivi dive into Charles E. Sellier Jr.’s 1984 Silent Night, Deadly Night! Topics include the Pixar of trauma, Christmas music that makes you want to commit a crime, and that new fitness fad of punching a Santa Claus in the face every year!

Cocktail – Egg Naughty or Nice

Consumed Creepy Content of the Week:

  1. ThanksKilling – Tubi
  2. Kristy – Netflix
  3. Holiday Hell – TubiTV
  4. Blood Rage – TubiTV

Make sure to check out this great article by Sharai from A Nightmare on Fierce Street if you’re looking for movies to watch and drinks to drink for the holidays! Cheers!

Eat, Drink, And Be Scary: A Thanksgiving and Cocktails Streaming Guide

Suggest a cocktail! Suggest a movie!

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

See Next Page for Transcript