Egg Naughty or Nice cocktail sits on a black table. The drink is white with a red tint near the bottom of the glass. A red Santa hat sits on the table next to it. In the background there is a fireplace with lit candles instead of firewood. There are two stockings hanging. One red and one green.

Egg Naughty or Nice | Silent Night, Deadly Night Themed Cocktail

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into Charles E. Sellier Jr.’s 1984 Silent Night, Deadly Night and couldn’t decide whether we’d be naughty or nice! Either way someone should be punished for how good this drink was! Cheers to kicking off the holiday horror season!

Ingredients

  • 6 oz Egg Nog
  • 1 oz Hennessey
  • 1 oz Bailey’s Red Velvet Cake Liqueur
  • Cinnamon

Directions

Step 1

In a glass, add egg nog, hennessey, and then red velvet cake liqueur. Stir with a bar spoon and garnish with a dash of cinnamon. Cheers!

Vivi Rating: 3

Erick Rating: 3.5

Shaken Not Scared Rating: 3.25

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

Flesh Fountain drink themed after the Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 sits on a black table with a skeleton in the background covered in lights. The drink is tan with red raspberry jam mixed around to give the blood and flesh look.

Flesh Fountain | The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 Themed Cocktail

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into Tobe Hooper’s 1986 The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 and join Enright in some of the Texas Battleland craziness by drinking from the Fountain of Flesh he opened up!

Ingredients

  • 2 oz Whiskey
  • 2 oz Kahlua
  • 2 oz Irish Cream
  • Raspberry jam

Directions

Step 1

In a blender, add whiskey, kahlua, irish cream, and ice. Blend!

Step 2

In a glass, layer raspberry jam at the bottom and add blended mix. Layer as much jam as you would like on top of the drink. Cheers!

Vivi Rating: 3

Erick Rating: 2

Shaken Not Scared Rating: 2.5

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

9/11 Tribute Shots sit in center of black table. The shot is layered red, white, and blue. In the background there is a lit black candle and a lit red candle. In between is a green Wiccapedia book with a tiara on top.

9/11 Tribute | Jennifer’s Body Themed Shot

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into Karyn Kusama’s 2009 Jennifer’s Body and are joined by the Queen of Shots Yessi! What better way to do that then to drink the same shot Jennifer drinks in the film!

Ingredients

  • Grenadine
  • Condensed Milk
  • Vodka
  • Blue Curacao

Directions

Step 1

In a glass, mix equal parts blue curacao and vodka.

Step 2

In a separate shot glass, add grenadine as first layer. Layer condensed milk second and then blue curacao/vodka mixture. Cheers!

Vivi Rating: 2

Erick Rating: 1

Yessi Rating: 2.5

Shaken Not Scared Rating: 1.8

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

Blood, Mud, & Boogers drink sits on black table in the middle of the forest. Sage and twigs lay on table in a very moody and dark photo. Dead leaves cover the ground below.

Blood, Mud, & Boogers | The Blair Witch Project Themed Cocktail

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into Daniel Myrick & Eduardo Sanchez’s 1999 The Blair Witch Project while drinking Mud, Blood, & Boogers!

Ingredients

  • Scotch
  • Grenadine
  • Midori

Directions

Step 1

In a glass with ice, layer equal parts grenadine, Midori, and scotch. Cheers!

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

Bar Dog Cabernet Sauvignon and Redemption Bourbon sit on black table in front of brick wall. The Bar Dog Sour sits in front and is a red layered drink with a lower layer of whiskey sour in a glass with ice.

Bar Dog Sour | Cujo Themed Cocktail

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into Lewis Teague’s 1983 Cujo with the help of our frequently mentioned friends from Boston, Brenda & Francisco while enjoying a Bar Dog Sour! One day we’ll make our own wine, but in the meantime enjoy this drink! Cheers!

Ingredients

Directions

Step 1

In a shaker combine whiskey, lemon juice, and simple syrup with ice. Shake!

Step 2

Strain into a glass with ice. Layer red wine to preference using a bar spoon or other utensil. Cheers!

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

Shiny stars hang in the background. Red roses lay on black table next to glass. Glass has the Pig's Blood drink garnished with Cherry. The drink is red with black layered on top.

Pig’s Blood | Carrie Themed Cocktail

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into Brian De Palma’s 1976 Carrie while drinking Pig’s Blood! Maybe if this was spilled on Carrie she would’ve been in a better mood…

Ingredients

  • 4 oz Agua De Jamaica
  • 1 oz White Rum
  • 1/2 oz Grand Marnier
  • 1 oz Dark Rum
  • Jamaica Flowers
  • Cherry

Directions

Step 1

In a shaker combine agua de jamaica, white rum, and grand marnier with ice. Shake!

Step 2

Strain into glass. Layer dark rum on top. Garnish with jamaica flowers and cherry. Cheers!

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

Saw cocktail sits in front of power drill, wrench, jar with screws, nails, etc. Drink is layered red with strawberry mixture and white with heavy cream vodka mixture for 4 total layers. Red and white swirl straw and strawberry added for garnish.

Saw | Saw Themed Cocktail

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into James Wan’s 2004 Saw with the help of a Jig & Saw!

Jig shot and Saw Cocktail sit on table together. Shot is red, black, and white. Cocktail is red, white, red, white to the top with strawberry and red and white swirl straw for garnish.

The Jig & Saw

Ingredients

  • 1 1/2 oz Rum
  • 1 1/2 oz Peach Schnapps
  • 1/2 oz Vodka
  • 1/2 oz Simple Syrup
  • 1 cup Heavy Whipping Cream
  • Frozen Strawberries
  • Grenadine
  • Vanilla Extract
  • Ice

Directions

Step 1

In a blender, add frozen strawberries about 2/3 to the top, rum, peach schnapps, simple syrup, grenadine, and ice. Blend!

Step 2

In separate bowl, add heavy whipping cream, vanilla extra, and vodka. Whip mixture until you get the consistency you are looking for. We went with a more fluffy consistency.

Step 3

In a hurricane glass, layer strawberry mixture first and then whipped cream vodka mixture for as many layers as desired. Garnish with a strawberry. Cheers!

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

Jig shot sits in front of power drill, wrench, and jar of screws, bolts, etc. Shot has grenadine for red, coffee liqueur for black, and heavy whipping cream with vodka for white.

Jig | Saw Themed Shot

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into James Wan’s 2004 Saw with the help of a Jig & Saw!

The Jig & Saw

Ingredients

  • 1 part Grenadine
  • 1 part Coffee Liqueur
  • Heavy Whipping Cream with Vodka (see Saw)

Directions

Step 1

In a shot glass, add grenadine to about 1/3.

Step 2

Layer coffee liqueur to 2/3 and leave room for third layer. Layer heavy whipping cream with vodka on top. Enjoy!

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!

Red candles are lit on a black candelabra. 2 red candle jars are lit as well and a skull mount candle holder also has a bleed black candle lit. Glass with cocktail sits in front with black and red cocktail mixed giving it the "fire face" look of the demon from the movie Insidious by James Wan. A strawberry is used to garnish and a black straw.

Fire Face Margarita | Insidious Themed Cocktail

Disclaimer
Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into James Wan’s Insidious while enjoying a Fire Face Margarita!

Ingredients

  • 1 oz Lime Juice
  • 1 oz Triple Sec
  • 1 1/2 oz Mezcal
  • 2 oz Pomegranate Juice
  • 1 1/2 oz Tequila Blanco
  • Activated charcoal
  • Frozen Strawberries
  • Ice

Directions

Step 1

In a blender, add strawberries, lime juice, triple sec, and mezcal. Blend away! Pour into a glass.

Step 2

Clean blender or use a second blender and add ice, pomegranate juice, activated charcoal, tequila Blanco. Blend again!

Step 3

Pour both mixes into a glass and layer as desired for “fire face demon” effect. Garnish. Enjoy!

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!