Rejected Proposal | The Strangers Themed Cocktail

Drink responsibly. This recipe contains alcohol and is for people that are 21 years of age or older. This drink does have an open flame so be sure not to leave the fire on for too long or drink when the glass is too hot. Always be careful when lighting any drink on fire or just don’t do it. Please be careful when using activated charcoal as it decreases how much your body absorbs and can reduce the effectiveness of medication.

Erick & Vivi dive into Bryan Bertino’s 2008 The Strangers while drinking what James should’ve been drinking instead of eating ice cream! The Rejected Proposal!


  • 2 oz Gin
  • 1 oz Elderflower Liqueur
  • 1/2 oz Simple Syrup
  • 1 oz Lime Juice
  • Rose Lemonade


Step 1

In a shaker, add gin, elderflower liqueur, simple syrup, and lime juice with ice. Shake!

Step 2

Strain into glass. Top with rose lemonade. Cheers!

Like the show? Take a second to support the Shaken Not Scared Podcast on Buy Me A Coffee!